I’ve just been busting at the seams to make another treat with cookie butter after making these Biscoff Layer Bars. I went ahead a purchased a jar. It sat on the counter for three days. I thought and thought about what I could make with it. I debated about just eating it with a spoon…I’m sure that would get the creative juices flowing, right?
I refrained.
I thought some more.
Then poof! I must have dreamed it because on a run one morning I thought of the peanut butter fudge topped with chocolate that my Mom used to make. Why couldn’t I do that with cookie butter?
*gasp* I could make a truffle and covered. it. in. chocolate!!!
And, that, my friend, is how this Three Ingredient Cookie Butter Truffle Recipe were born!
Three Ingredient Cookie Butter Truffles are literally what dreams are made of! Sweet and creamy cookie butter is elevated to superior status with the addition of confectioners’ sugar and decadent white chocolate.
It’s a flavor bomb of epic proportions.
It’s the Woodstock of the truffle world!
What I’m trying to say is, “It. Is. Really. Good.”
Then after all that cookie butter and white chocolate goodness, I gave them a little blig with a sprinkle of red sugar just to dress them up a bit.
Cookie butter truffles make regular chocolate or peanut butter truffles unapologetically jealous. With good reason!
You can purchase or look at the jar of Cookie Butter here and here.
Need a quick gift?
These Three Ingredient Cookie Butter Truffle Recipe would be perfect. You could bag these in a pretty clear candy bag and tie with a festive ribbon. I can assure you these truffles will be well received! That is if you can party with them…
Keep scrolling down for Three Ingredient Cookie Butter Truffle Recipe
One month ago: Basic Cheesecake Cookie Cups
One year ago: White Chocolate Walnut Blondies
More deliciousness!
Three Ingredient Cookie Butter Truffle Recipe
Want to save recipes? Create an account or login & then you can use the “Save Recipe” button when viewing a recipe to save it to your Recipe Box. You can access your saved recipes on any device and generate a shopping list for recipes in your collections.
Save To Your Recipe BoxIngredients
- 1 and ¼ cup cookie butter like this
- 1 cup confectioner's sugar sifted
- 1 and ½ cup white or milk chocolate candy melts I like these
Instructions
- Cream cookie butter and sugar together in a mixer. Mixture should be thick but sticky enough to form a ball and hold together. Add more cookie butter, 1 Tablespoon at a time if it doesn't stick together.
- I used a small ice cream scoop to get even amounts.
- Scoop it into a ball, roll in your palms
- Place ball on a cookie sheet lined with waxed paper or parchment paper.
- Freeze 15 minutes.
- Melt chocolate in microwave.
- Dip truffles in chocolate and place back on paper to dry.
Notes
Nutrition
This post contains affiliate links. If you click the link and make a purchase I will receive a small commission at no cost to you. Visit all my recommended products at Paula’s Picks on Amazon. Read my entire Privacy Policy here.
Sue says
Can someone tell me what ‘ cookie butter’ is thanks Sue
Paula says
it’s a paste like peanut butter but made from cookies>> https://amzn.to/2QLNJ4y
Esther Abril says
If anyone lives near a Trader Joe’s they sell cookie butter. I buy it all the time. My family loves it. I made one batch of these last week and everyone hobbled them up. So I went and bought four jars on Saturday because I’m making a bunch of these on Wednesday 😁. We have our family and friends gathering and these were requested.
Bea says
You can buy it at Walmart the cheapest
Paula Avrit says
Where is it located at Walmart?
Paula says
By the peanut butter
Suzanne Renae says
I love cookie butter on toast, but I am pretty certain that I would love it even more in truffles. Brilliant idea!
Paula says
I love cookie butter, I’ve actually never put it on toast. I usually eat it by the spoonfuls!
Jessica says
Do you think it would work if I mixed the butter and sugar tonight and let it sit in the fridge over night and dip them in chocolate tomorrow?
Lynne schwarz says
Do they have cookie butter in northern California?
Layla @ Brunch Time Baker says
This is such a great recipe, Love the simplicity!!
Paula says
Thank you, Layla. I love a good, quick recipe… I’m so impatient 🙂
Heather @ Sugar Dish Me says
First of all, I love truffles. But also I love Biscoff!!! And now Paula, I love you. 🙂
Have a Merry Christmas!!!
Paula says
You tickle me!!! I just so happen to be the same way and these babies were Crack!!
Joan - My Cookie Clinic says
Paula, You’re so creative; I have to follow a recipe. I’ve never heard of cookie butter. I wonder if the grocers sell it here in Northern VA. These look delicious and love the festive red sugar!
Paula says
I bet they do, Joan. If MS stores have it surely you guys do! 🙂 In Walmart it’s with the peanut butter. Biscoff is the only brand I’ve seen. I bet it would be pretty easy to make it with the Biscoff cookies though. (Which I may try next.) I baked cakes for a restaurant in town for a couple of years and I really kind of learned what I could substitute and still get a good outcome while I was doing that. I got so tired of making the same cakes week after week I got creative.
tanya says
Oh boy, these could be trouble. I have a cookie butter addiction. I can’t imagine how many of these beautiful truffle I could eat in day!
Paula says
So true, Tanya! I hid them from the family…that’s not bad is it?
Kelly says
These truffles are pure genius Paula! I love how pretty they look 🙂 I love Biscoff and it’s so hard for me not to eat it by the spoonful but making them into truffles is such a wonderful idea! These would be a sure hit and gone in a flash 🙂 Pinning 🙂
Paula says
I totally agree. I made them for my candy trays that I usually give to neighbors, then I didn’t want to give them away! 🙂
barbara kennedy says
I HAVE NEVER HEARD OF COOKIE BUTTER, WHERE CAN I BUY IT? REPLY.
Paula says
The only brand of Cookie butter that I see is Biscoff. In my grocery store it is displayed where the peanut butters and Nutella is. Usually, it has a red lid and white label, but it’s been a while since I bought some so that may have changed. Here’s a link to it on Amazon so you can see the jar. http://astore.amazon.com/camepm-20?_encoding=UTF8&node=8
Keshia says
Not sure where you are and if there is one close by, but Trader Joe’s has Cookie Butter, too. It is very good and made of Speculoos Cookies.
barbara kennedy says
I HAVE NEVER HEARD OF COOKIE BUTTER, WHERE CAN I BUY IT? REPLY.